A modified gross lease is a commercial lease where the tenant pays one rent that includes some operating expenses, and the tenant picks up its share of any increase above a set baseline. That baseline is either a base year (the actual expenses in the first lease year) or a fixed expense stop (a dollar amount per square foot).
If you've ever bought a building where the seller called every lease "NNN" and then found a stack of modified gross leases in the files, you know why this matters. Your expenses go up, but only part of that increase gets billed back. The rest comes out of your net operating income. Here's how base years and expense stops actually work, with a calculator and chart to model them.
What a modified gross lease is
Think of the three main lease types on a line. On one end is a triple net (NNN) lease, where the tenant pays base rent plus its share of taxes, insurance, and common area maintenance. On the other end is a full service gross lease, where the landlord pays everything out of one rent. A modified gross lease sits in the middle.
The landlord covers expenses up to a baseline. The tenant pays its pro rata share of anything above it. Tenants get a predictable first year. Landlords get protection against long term cost growth. I compare all three in detail in triple net vs gross vs modified gross, so this post focuses on the mechanics of the baseline.
How a base year works
With a base year, the baseline is whatever the building actually costs to operate in the first year of the lease (usually a calendar year). Every year after that, the landlord compares actual expenses to the base year and bills the tenant its share of the increase.
Example numbers. A 20,000 square foot building costs $120,000 a year to operate in the base year, or $6.00 a foot. The tenant leases 2,500 feet, which is a 12.5% share. In year two, expenses rise to $124,800, or $6.24 a foot. The tenant pays $0.24 times 2,500, or $600 for the year.
That doesn't sound like much. The point is that it compounds. By year seven at 4% growth, the increase is about $1.59 a foot, and the tenant's annual pass through is close to $4,000.
How an expense stop works
An expense stop sets the baseline as a fixed number instead of the actual first year. The lease might say "landlord pays operating expenses up to $6.00 per square foot, tenant pays its share above that." The stop doesn't move.
The difference matters when the first year is unusual. If the building is half empty or the tax assessment is about to jump, a base year locks in a low baseline (good for the landlord) or a high baseline (good for the tenant), depending on which way things are moving. A fixed stop takes the guesswork out, as long as you set it at a realistic number.
Expense stop calculator and chart
Plug in your building's numbers to see what a tenant pays over the term under a base year or a fixed stop. Watch how quickly the pass through grows in the chart.
Expense stop calculator
Example defaults. Change any input. Assumes expenses grow at a steady rate and the tenant pays its pro rata share of increases over the base year.
Tenant pro rata share: 0%
Total tenant pass through over the term: $0
| Year | Building expenses | Per SF | Over the stop (per SF) | Tenant pays |
|---|
Gross up clauses on a partially vacant building
Some expenses go up and down with occupancy, like janitorial, utilities, and management fees. If your base year happens while the building is 60% leased, those expenses look artificially low. As you lease up, they rise, and the landlord would bill tenants for "increases" that are really just more occupancy.
A gross up clause fixes that. It adjusts the variable expenses to what they'd be at a set occupancy (often 95% or 100%) for both the base year and later years, so the comparison is fair. Landlords want it to avoid an artificially low base year. Tenants want it to avoid paying for lease up. Both sides should read it carefully.
What landlords should watch
- Leases sold as NNN that aren't. Read every lease, not the rent roll summary. A building of modified gross leases is worth less than the same rent on NNN leases, because the landlord carries the baseline expenses.
- Base years that are about to reset. A new tenant gets a new base year. If expenses jumped last year, the new baseline is higher and your recovery is lower.
- Tax reassessment after you buy. In many places your purchase triggers a new assessment. On a modified gross lease, the tenant pays only its share of the increase above the stop. Underwrite it.
- Expense exclusions. Capital improvements, leasing commissions, and financing costs usually can't be passed through.
What tenants should negotiate
- A cap on controllable expense increases (everything except taxes, insurance, and utilities)
- A base year that reflects a normal, stabilized year, with a gross up if the building isn't full
- Audit rights on the annual reconciliation
- A clear list of what can't be included as an operating expense
The annual reconciliation is where all of this shows up as a bill. I walk through that process in my guide to CAM charges.
How to underwrite a modified gross lease
When you underwrite, model expenses as a total, then subtract what tenants will reimburse. Under NNN, recoveries track expenses almost one for one. Under a modified gross lease, recoveries only cover the slice above each tenant's baseline. Your net operating income is base rent plus recoveries, minus total expenses.
Two leases with the same rent can produce very different NOI. Run each lease separately for the first few years, and don't assume recoveries you can't point to in the lease language.
Frequently asked questions
What is a modified gross lease?
A modified gross lease is a commercial lease where the rent includes some operating expenses up to a baseline, and the tenant pays its share of increases above that baseline. It sits between a triple net lease and a full service gross lease.
What is the difference between a base year and an expense stop?
A base year sets the baseline at the building's actual expenses in the first lease year. An expense stop sets the baseline at a fixed dollar amount per square foot written into the lease. The base year moves with the real numbers, the stop does not.
Who pays property taxes in a modified gross lease?
The landlord pays property taxes up to the baseline, and the tenant pays its pro rata share of any increase above it, if taxes are included in the operating expenses the lease passes through. Read the lease to confirm.
What is a gross up clause?
A gross up clause adjusts variable operating expenses to what they would be at a set occupancy, often 95 percent or 100 percent, so a partially vacant building does not create an artificially low base year or overbill tenants as the building leases up.
Is a modified gross lease good for landlords?
It can be. The landlord can quote a simple rent and still pass through future cost increases. But the landlord pays the baseline expenses, so the building typically produces less net income than the same rent on a triple net lease.
Underwriting a building with modified gross leases? We walk through rent rolls like this line by line in the CRE Central Accelerator.
Learn About the Accelerator